Why is your oven cooking unevenly? Troubleshooting common problems

Imagine the anticipation of a delicious home-cooked meal, carefully prepared and placed in the oven, only to discover that your dish is unevenly cooked or still cold in the centre! It’s a frustrating experience that can turn a promising meal into a culinary disappointment. If your oven is cooking unevenly, there may be several reasons why this may be happening. We troubleshoot common problems and share simple fixes so that your oven can once again function at its best.

Reasons why your oven is cooking unevenly:

Blocked or obstructed airflow

Ovens rely on proper airflow to distribute heat evenly. If the airflow is obstructed, some areas might get hotter than others, resulting in uneven cooking results.

• Make sure there’s enough space around your dishes. Overcrowding can block airflow, so try to leave adequate space between pans and the walls of the oven.
• Ensure that the vents inside your oven are not obstructed. Lining your racks with alfoil may be great for cleanup but it can sometimes restrict airflow.

Hot spots in the oven

Ovens can have natural hot spots that can cause your food to cook unevenly.

• To combat hot spots, try rotating your dishes halfway through the cooking time. This helps ensure that all parts of the dish are exposed to similar temperatures.

Handy hint! An easy way to check for hotspots is to test it with bread. Preheat your oven and place a few slices of bread on the rack. Monitor to see if some pieces are more cooked than others.

Faulty heating element

If your element isn’t glowing bright orange when fully heated, or your oven is cooking unevenly and your food is taking longer to cook, it could be a sign that you have a damaged heating element that needs to replaced.

• Check the heating element for visible signs of damage, such as cracks, blistering or breaks. If it’s not glowing evenly or at all, it might be faulty. A simple way to identify which of your oven elements is not working, is use the oven function selector to select each heating function in turn.

You can often replace a faulty heating element relatively easily. Consult your manual for guidance, or check out our video with easy step by step instructions.

Poor oven insulation

The oven door seal (or gasket) ensures that heat stays inside the oven. A damaged or worn-out seal can cause heat to escape, leading to uneven cooking temperatures and poor energy efficiency. You will need to replace a worn or damaged oven door seal.

• Inspect the oven door seal for any signs of wear and tear. The door seal needs to be intact and must form a tight seal when the door is closed.
• Replace your seal easily with our handy guide.

Handy hint! A simple way to test the seal is to close a piece of paper in the oven door; if it pulls out easily, the seal may need replacement.

Opening the door too often

Opening the door frequently while baking can cause hot air to escape and significant drops in temperature which can lead to uneven cooking.

• Instead of opening the door frequently, keep your oven light on and check the progress of your food through the window.

Incorrect rack placement

The position of the racks can affect how evenly your food cooks. For even heat distribution, leave enough space between the racks to allow hot air to circulate freely.

Recipes often suggest placing dishes on specific racks for optimal results:

• Place the racks in the middle positions for most standard baking and roasting recipes.
• For dishes that require more browning on the top, such as casseroles or gratins, position the rack closer to the upper third of the oven.
• Use the lower rack position for items that need more bottom heat, like pizza or bread.

Consider rotating the position of the baking sheets or pans halfway through cooking for even browning.

• If you’re getting uneven results, try adjusting the rack position. Moving your dish higher or lower can sometimes help achieve more even cooking.

Thermostat issues

If the oven’s thermostat is malfunctioning, it may not maintain a consistent temperature. Calibration or replacement may be necessary.

• Like the overall temperature, the thermostat can sometimes be recalibrated if it’s not accurate.  To test, set the oven to a specific temperature than place an oven-safe thermometer insider. Check the thermometer’s temperature to see if it is the same as your oven settings.
• Check your manual for specific instructions on recalibrating, as the process can vary by model and brand. If recalibration doesn’t help, the thermostat might need to be replaced.

Not preheating your oven

Skipping the preheat step or not allowing the oven to preheat fully can result in uneven cooking, as the temperature won’t be consistent throughout the cooking process.

• Make it a habit to preheat your oven to the required temperature before placing your dishes inside.

By addressing these common problems, you can enjoy more reliable cooking and baking results. If you’ve tried these fixes and your oven is still cooking unevenly, you may need to consult a qualified service technician.

Need spare parts for your oven?

At Statewide Appliance Spares, we offer a wide range of replacement parts and accessories to keep your oven operating at its best. From heating elements and globes to seals and doors, we’ve got you covered.

All the latest tips on the Statewide blog

Visit the Statewide blog where you can find our complete guide to oven care and maintenance.

Check out our YouTube channel

Need help with your home appliance repairs and maintenance? Check out our DIY videos on our YouTube Channel. All the expert hints and tips to make appliance repairs a breeze!